In this guide

Medical Guardian and Bay Alarm Medical are two of the best-known medical alert companies in the U.S. Both offer 24/7 professional monitoring, in-home and on-the-go devices, optional fall detection, and no long-term contract. The biggest differences are how you pay: Medical Guardian’s lowest prices need an annual plan, while Bay Alarm Medical’s are month-to-month but you buy the device for mobile plans.

The short answer:

  • Choose Bay Alarm Medical if you want the lowest monthly price without prepaying for a year, a short no-fee way out, or a mobile device or smartwatch at a lower monthly rate.
  • Choose Medical Guardian if you’re happy to pay yearly, or want a mobile device without buying the hardware. Its device fees are often waived in promotions.

We haven’t tested these devices ourselves. This comparison is based on each company’s published prices and terms, checked on their websites on October 15, 2026, and independent reviews, cited throughout. Medical alert prices and promotions change often, so confirm current prices before you buy. We have no business relationship with either company.

At a glance

Medical Guardian Bay Alarm Medical
In-home, landline As low as $27.95/month* $27.95/month
In-home, cellular As low as $34.95/month* $34.95/month, no device fee
Mobile (GPS) MG Mini from $42.95/month* SOS Micro or All-In-One 2, $34.95/month + device
Smartwatch MG Move from $44.95/month* SOS Smartwatch, $39.95/month + device
Fall detection +$10/month +$10/month
Device fees Some devices list $149.95, often waived in promotions Mobile and smartwatch devices must be bought ($149 to $199 list, often discounted)
Trial / refund Prorated refund of prepaid service after cancelling 15-day trial with full refund, less shipping
Cancellation fees “Restocking fees may apply”; “cancellation fees may apply” None, per its FAQ
Monitoring Five Diamond certified center Five Diamond (CSAA) certified, UL-listed centers in Utah and Idaho

Prices from each company’s website, checked October 15, 2026 (Medical Guardian; Bay Alarm Medical). *Medical Guardian’s “as low as” prices reflect its annual plan; month-to-month is higher (for example, its Guardian Flex was $39.95/month on the annual plan and $44.95 month-to-month). Prices and promotions change often.

Devices and prices

Medical Guardian

Medical Guardian sells in-home systems, mobile GPS devices, and wearables1:

“As low as” means the annual plan rate. Paying monthly costs more, so compare like with like. Fall detection costs $10 a month extra.

Bay Alarm Medical

Bay Alarm Medical lists month-to-month prices and says there are no activation fees5:

  • SOS Home (landline): $27.95 a month, no device fee.
  • SOS Home (cellular): $34.95 a month, or $44.95 with fall detection, with a free device.
  • SOS Micro: a small wearable for home and away, $34.95 a month, or $44.95 with fall detection, plus a device purchase ($149 list; $104.30 on sale when we checked).
  • SOS All-In-One 2: a mobile device plus an in-home button, $34.95 a month, or $44.95 with fall detection, plus a device purchase ($149 list; $89.40 on sale when we checked).
  • SOS Smartwatch: $39.95 a month, or $49.95 with fall detection, plus a device purchase ($199 list; $159.20 on sale when we checked).

Device purchase is required for the All-In-One, mobile, and smartwatch plans, so add that one-time cost when you compare.

The real monthly cost

When you compare, add up everything: the monthly fee, fall detection ($10), any device fee (spread over how long you expect to keep the service), extra buttons or wall buttons, and shipping. Paying quarterly or yearly often lowers the monthly rate, but you pay more upfront, and it matters more if you cancel early.

Fall detection

Both companies offer automatic fall detection as an add-on, for $10 a month. If the device senses a fall and the person can’t press the button, it calls the monitoring center automatically.

Two things to know:

  • It doesn’t catch every fall. Slow slides to the floor, for example, may not trigger it. The person should still press the button if they can.
  • False alarms happen. The monitoring center will check in, and that’s fine. Better a false alarm than a missed fall.

If the person lives alone, has fallen before, or has a condition that causes dizziness or fainting, fall detection is usually worth the extra $10.

Monitoring

Both companies use U.S.-based monitoring centers with Five Diamond certification, a designation from The Monitoring Association for centers that meet its standards for operator training and service45. Bay Alarm Medical says its centers are in Utah and Idaho and are UL-listed. We haven’t measured response times ourselves, and we haven’t found an independent test of both that we could cite. You can test this yourself: press the button during the trial period and time how long it takes to reach someone.

Contracts, cancellation, and refunds

Neither company requires a long-term contract, but read the terms before you sign. Cancelling isn’t as simple as stopping payment.

Medical Guardian: you cancel by calling 800-313-1191. Service ends on the day it receives the equipment (or, if you bought the equipment, a signed cancellation letter). You then get a prorated refund of any prepaid, unused service. Its policy says restocking fees may apply, refunds and cancellations can take up to 30 days to process, and a footnote adds that cancellation fees may apply6. Ask exactly which fees apply to your plan, and get the answer in writing.

Bay Alarm Medical: it says it doesn’t hold customers to contracts or charge cancellation fees. It offers a 15-day trial: return the device within 15 days for a full refund, less shipping. After that, you get a prorated refund for unused months, less shipping. The account isn’t fully cancelled until the device is returned in working condition and processed7. Some customers have complained about slow refunds8.

For either company:

  • Return equipment with tracking, and keep the receipt.
  • Get your cancellation confirmed in writing.
  • If you prepay for a year, ask exactly how much you’d get back if you cancel after one, three, or six months.

Watch out for sales pressure

Medical alerts are often sold by phone, and sometimes after a fall or a scare, when families feel rushed. Both companies are well established, but the same rules apply to any medical alert purchase:

  • Don’t let a “today only” price rush you. Promotions come around often.
  • Ask for the total first-year cost in writing, including devices, fall detection, add-ons, and shipping.
  • Decline add-ons you don’t need, such as extra buttons, lockboxes, or app subscriptions, unless they’ll really be used.
  • Ask about the trial or return period before you pay, and put a reminder in your calendar before it ends.
  • Be wary of unsolicited calls offering a “free” medical alert system. Scammers use this pitch, and real companies don’t need your Medicare number to sell you a device.

Which should you choose?

If the person… Consider
Is mostly at home, and you don’t want to prepay for a year Bay Alarm Medical SOS Home
Is mostly at home, and you’re happy to pay yearly Either; prices are about the same
Has no landline Either company’s cellular home system
Is active and often out alone Bay Alarm SOS Micro or All-In-One 2 for a lower monthly fee; Medical Guardian MG Mini or Guardian Flex to avoid buying the device
Wants a watch instead of a pendant Bay Alarm SOS Smartwatch ($39.95 + device) or Medical Guardian MG Move (from $44.95)
Is at higher risk of falls Either company, with fall detection

The best device is the one the person will actually wear, every day, including in the shower, where many falls happen. Check that the help button is waterproof, and involve the person in choosing it.

Paying for a medical alert system

Original Medicare doesn’t pay for medical alert systems. Some Medicare Advantage plans, state Medicaid waiver programs, and your local Area Agency on Aging may help with the cost. You may also be able to use HSA or FSA money; check with your plan administrator.

The bottom line

Both are established choices with 24/7 U.S.-based, Five Diamond certified monitoring. Their starting prices are almost identical. Bay Alarm Medical wins if you want month-to-month pricing, a 15-day trial, and no cancellation fees. Medical Guardian suits people who’ll pay yearly, or who want a mobile device without buying the hardware. Whichever you choose, compare the total cost including fall detection and device fees, read the cancellation terms, and test the button during the trial.

Sources

  1. Medical Guardian, medicalguardian.com
  2. Medical Guardian, medicalguardian.com
  3. Medical Guardian, medicalguardian.com
  4. Medical Guardian, medicalguardian.com
  5. Bay Alarm Medical, bayalarmmedical.com
  6. Medical Guardian, medicalguardian.com
  7. Bay Alarm Medical, bayalarmmedical.com
  8. BBB, bbb.org

Frequently asked questions

Is Medical Guardian or Bay Alarm Medical cheaper?
Their starting prices are almost the same. Both list in-home landline systems from $27.95 a month and cellular in-home systems from $34.95 a month. The difference is in how you pay. Medical Guardian's "as low as" prices are for its annual plan, and month-to-month costs more. Bay Alarm Medical's listed prices are month-to-month. Bay Alarm's mobile devices and smartwatch also cost a few dollars less per month, but you buy the device. Both charge $10 a month extra for automatic fall detection.
Do Medical Guardian and Bay Alarm Medical require a contract?
Bay Alarm Medical says it doesn't hold customers to contracts or charge cancellation fees. Medical Guardian lets you cancel by phone but says restocking and cancellation fees may apply. With both, the account isn't fully closed until the equipment is returned, and refunds can take weeks. Read the service agreement before you sign.
Which has better fall detection?
Both offer automatic fall detection as an add-on for $10 a month on most devices. No fall detection system catches every fall, and false alarms happen, so the person should still press the button if they can. Ask each company which of its devices support fall detection before you buy.
Do these systems work without a landline?
Yes. Both companies sell cellular in-home systems and mobile GPS devices that work on a cellular network, so you don't need a landline. Check coverage at the person's address, especially in rural areas.
Does Medicare pay for Medical Guardian or Bay Alarm Medical?
Original Medicare doesn't pay for medical alert systems. Some Medicare Advantage plans, state Medicaid waiver programs, and local aging programs may help with the cost. You may also be able to use HSA or FSA money; check with your plan administrator.
Which is better for someone who leaves the house often?
Both sell mobile devices with GPS and two-way talk, plus a smartwatch. Medical Guardian's mobile and wearable devices often come without a device fee during promotions; Bay Alarm Medical's cost less per month but you buy the device. The best fit depends on which device the person will actually wear every day.

This guide is general consumer information, not medical or professional advice. For your own situation, talk to a doctor, an occupational therapist or a qualified installer. In an emergency, call 911. See our disclaimer.